McSorley’s Old Ale House

New York Magazine writes:


No matter how long you’ve lived in Fun City, you can’t really claim residency until you’ve helped out a carful of Jersey kids demanding directions to “Mig-sahw-leez!” Like most Fodor’s-approved destinations, this ancient taproom’s modest appeal has been eclipsed by its resolutely un-hip reputation. Mugs of house-brand ale are served in pairs (like Twinkies)—one light, one dark (with your eyes closed, they taste identical). If you order anything off the spartan menu, make it the cheese and onion plate: The big slice of raw onion and hunks of sharp cheddar will arm-wrestle your senses to a draw, overpowering even the bouquet of more than a hundred years of spilt ale soaked into everything.

ExtraThe men’s room urinals are spectacular porcelain sarcophagi big enough to contain a body. The ladies’ room fixtures are decidedly less impressive, however, as women have only been admitted (by court order) since 1970.


Listing Information

Bar,Casual Dining,Dinner,Late Night,Lunch,Pub/Bistro

Cheap - Under $10


Not Accepted


No Parking

Not Necessary

Not Available

Not Available

Visited 1124 times, 1 Visits today

Add a Review

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Related Listings

  • Polo Bar

    Polo Bar

    We Say: If you like Clubby, Wood and Leather, with Classic American Cuisine, then this is the place for you. The staff is still getting the hang of breaking in their saddles. There is no question Ralph hit another home run with this one. It may take a few months… Read more »

  • Tavern On the Green

    Tavern On the Green

    ABOUT TAVERN ON THE GREEN A modern tavern nestled in a bucolic Central Park setting, Tavern on the Green is an iconic, landmark restaurant unlike any other. Centered around a hearty, rustic menu shaped by local, seasonal ingredients, Tavern on the Green invites patrons into a warm, celebratory gathering space that captures… Read more »

  • One if by Land, Two if by Sea

    One if by Land, Two if by Sea

    New York Restaurants writes: Profile New Yorkers may agree on very little, but this pricey classic gets a landslide vote for New York’s most romantic dining experience. Sit in what was once Aaron Burr’s carriage house—surrounded by flowers, warmed by dual fireplaces, lulled by the mellow stylings of the resident… Read more »